This day in geek history: August 16


Sign directing attendees to some of of the exhibits and activities of the 1973 San Diego Comic-Con. Also notice, that about half of the people pictured are women.

First convention officially named San Diego Comic-Con. The convention that was to become Comic-Con started in 1970 and was called the Golden State Comic-Minicon, but in 1973 the convention officially changed its name to the San Diego Comic-Con and expanded to 5 days.

And please, PLEASE check out the pictures from that 1973 convention. They are eerily familiar. Most of the elements from today's convention have their seeds back then.

San Diego Comic-Con: Counting cosplayers

The Whovian cosplay meetup!

I don't know what possessed me this year, but I started wondering about the percentage of Comic-Con attendees that cosplay. I know part of the motivation is that there is almost no cosplay on Wednesday's Preview Night (there's some, but very few and it's very casual), and on Thursday there is a significant and noticeable increase in the percentage of people in costume.

So I started rough counting cosplayers vs. non-cosplayers. I would take a representative sample periodically through the day, and it would be wherever it occurred to me. I'd count while waiting in line for a panel, and when I was on the exhibition floor, and while walking through the Sails Pavilion. I didn't count outside of the convention center because I decided to just limit myself to people who had passes. And since it was all in my head, i tended to round off a lot. The numbers are definitely approximate!

My criteria for identifying someone in costume was subjective. My cutoff was whether someone was clearly portraying a character. Just putting on a Batman shirt or wearing cat ears in your hair wasn't enough to be counted as a costume. I didn't have to recognize the character (there were plenty which I couldn't identify), but I needed to be able to tell that someone was wearing a costume.

There are plenty of weaknesses in this count, but it's the first set of statistics of this kind that I've seen. In the future I'm going to do a better job at data collection. This time I only wrote down the daily numbers in some Facebook posts, and here I'm collecting the numbers from those posts.

So, with all of those caveats, here are my day to day statistics of attendees who were cosplaying:

  • Wednesday, 0, 0%,
    • I didn't actually count on Wednesday, but it was extremely small
  • Thursday, 1 in 10, 10%
  • Friday, 1 in 7, 15%
  • Saturday, 1 in 4, 25%
    • There were a LOT of cosplayers in groups, so the count kept changing
  • Sunday, 1 in 20, 5%

Busiest cosplay day, Saturday with about 1 in 4 people in costume. There are a LOT of cosplayers, and there are a lot of groups. Not necessarily groups with a common theme, just groups of friends all of whom were cosplaying.

Slowest cosplay day (other than the Wed. preview night) is Sunday with about 1 in 20 people in costume. It's a dramatic shift from the day before, and it's very noticeable. Sunday is the last day to sell out tickets, so my bet is that the majority of Sunday attendees only have the one day at the con, and so they are focused on the exhibition hall and getting to as many booths as possible. Cosplay takes a back seat for those people. That's just a guess on my part.

San Diego Comic-Con 2014: Summary

The street banners are my first sign that I'm at Comic-Con

It's all over but the sorting and post-con repairs

Sorry about the delay, but I finally recovered from the trip: unpacking, catching up on sleep, sorting through photos, organizing purchases, putting away costumes, and dealing with life. Even this quick overview took some time (and yeah, it's BIG). All my real-time updates (more or less) took place at my Facebook page, and I plan on writing up some more detailed discussions later.

General impressions

Referred to as Line-Con, this is where you meet & chat with other geeks making temporary friendships.

I'm seeing a lot of discussion about whether Comic-Con was smaller this year or had fewer vendors - especially the movie studios. I haven't seen any numbers that would support this, but if their were fewer movies, the studios had way more TV shows represented.

My general impression is that the con itself was as big as last year and the year before. It's not getting any bigger, and it's certainly not getting any smaller. Because, you know, it's maxed out

A moment of madness on the exhibition floor

The booths seemed as crowded and the lines into the panels seemed as long (but better controlled). The lines to get INTO Comic-Con (the big morning line) seemed longer than last year. You needed to get up even earlier than before, and when I left the con at night, the line (which already starts up for the next morning) seemed longer than I remember. And the lines for buying convention exclusives from the major vendors seemed to fill up sooner.

A fairly quiet Sunday morning in the Gaslamp District. Normally this intersection is packed with people.

Outside the convention center, it seemed as big as ever, although I've heard some reports that there were fewer buildings in the Gaslamp District taken over by vendors because the locals had jacked up prices. However, the number of off site events seemed more than last year. I got to very few, mainly because I had plenty to do on site. If I ever miss out on a full set of tickets (very likely because of the lottery system in place), there is plenty to do off site.

Even though I don't attend movie panels, I'll agree with the statements that there didn't seem to be the same magic moments that occurred in past years, such as: Loki talking to the audience on stage in full armor, the entire cast of avengers with Joss Whedon, Batman v. Superman reveal, etc. Our expectations are set very high at Comic-Con.

Comics & Artwork

The comics and books I brought back from the convention

Comics are the heart of Comic-Con. Don't let anyone tell you otherwise. Every major publishing house, all the secondary publishers, and more indie and small publishers than you'll find anywhere else in the US. A third of the panels are about comics, the Eisner awards take place at Comic-Con, the Artists' Alley is amazing, and there are organized meet and greets between publishers and would be creators. Add to that all of the behind the scenes meetings between the creators, editors, and publishers discussing deals, projects, and future plans and you have the industry's main convention.

I love talking with the publishers and creators. Most of what you see in the photo comes from small publishers that I got to sign their work. An amazing range of artists are in Artists' Alley and most are more than willing to chat about their work or just about any geeky topic. Prices are reasonable and many will still do free sketches. I've heard that there are other, better artist conventions, but I've always found Comic-Con to be a great time to interact with artists.

Original page from World's Finest, issue #26, Page 1. Drawn by Tyler Kirkham, inked by Joe Weems

Print of Lady Mechanika, drawn by Joe Benitez, inked by Joe Weems

Print from Sho Murase

I didn't buy as much artwork as I usually do. No particular reason, I just wasn't as inspired this year. I did buy an original page from World's Finest, the first page from issue 26. I bought it from Joe Weems (the inker) and it was drawn by Tyler Kirkham. He also threw in this print from one of my favorite comics, Lady Mechanika, created and drawn by Joe Benitez and inked by Weems. I also bought a print from Sho Murase, from whom I've bought quite a few prints over the years, 

Apparently we weren't allowed to take pictures. After I snapped this one, I was asked by an usher to stop. This is Professor William H. Foster III who accepted the award for Orrin C. Evans, the publisher of  All Negro Comics #1  (1947), and was accepted into the Will Eisner Comic Awards Hall of Fame

Apparently we weren't allowed to take pictures. After I snapped this one, I was asked by an usher to stop. This is Professor William H. Foster III who accepted the award for Orrin C. Evans, the publisher of All Negro Comics #1 (1947), and was accepted into the Will Eisner Comic Awards Hall of Fame

The Eisner awards are to comic books what the Hugos are to science fiction. Or, for a less geeky reference, what the Oscars are to movies. Awards are given by a fairly prestigious set of presenters to creators who are dressed up and on good behavior. It's an interesting and surprisingly fun event, and the nomination list is a big part of my Comic-Con shopping list.

Hare are the links for this year's nomination list and the list of winners.

Cosplay & Masquerade

Okay, here's where I'm going to admit to an embarrassing moment. I brought two costumes with me, and I planned on wearing both. I was feeling pretty smug that I had new bags for both of them. I had prepared makeup for the first time and was ready to wear it while playing Malgus.

And then I discovered that I was missing several key parts of the Darth Malgus costume. I searched everywhere, and it became clear that I just hadn't transferred all the costume from the old bag to the new. So, no Malgus costume at this convention. Ouch, ouch ouch.

The Deviant Art folks (who sponsor Artists' Alley), were excited to have me chop off the head of their mascot.

Luckily the Headless Horseman costume was complete, so I spent extra time in that character (about 4 hours rather than my usual 2). I was completely wiped after such a long time in a difficult costume, but it was totally worth it.

Of course, the cosplay that I saw was amazing. I've attached a gallery here, and of course, it's just the stuff that I saw and could get a picture of. That's just a small fraction of the total number of amazing costumes and you can easily search for photo galleries, music videos, and YouTube summaries of a lot more cosplayers. Each day I tried to get a rough count on the percentage of cosplayers, and I'll put all that into a separate post.

I was also able to talk with some suppliers. I ended up buying my first wig that's intended for a new character (I've bought cheap wigs as improv props before). It was great directly talking with the guys in the Epic Cosplay booth (yeah, two guys), because they immediately looked up the character I was planning, found a wig that was close in color length and style, and talked with me about how to alter it. It was fantastic help. Once again, the advantage of going to a con! I'll talk about the wig in future progress reports.

The SCA Iron Brigade demonstrating full contact dueling.

There's an area set aside for fan based organizations, and there are a lot with tables and information. They vary from the Legion World (a fan group for the Legion of Superheroes), to Califur (the Southern California Furry Convention), the IKV Stranglehold (discussed later), and so many more. But the big draw for me is the live medieval combat demonstrations put on by the SCA Iron Brigade. It's one-on-one dueling, and looks great. You can feel the impact of a big ol' sword smacking onto a shield or armor helmet. Full contact cosplay!

There were several cosplay oriented panels, although the only one I made it to was about adding special effects to cosplay photos and videos. Cosplay Dreams 3D is a pretty cool documentary that's a real love fest for cosplayers. But in addition to talking with cosplayers, they took video in 3D of the cosplayers at conventions, and then added a variety of special effects. This made the footage into something magical! It was delightful to see these cosplayers, at conventions I know, suddenly have their character's special abilities come to life. I recommend seeing the clips on their website, or at any convention you can find them. Seeing what they were able to do was fantastic. I'm not sure I'm ready to dive in and spend the time they do, but I was inspired!

One of the many cosplay skits at the 40th annual Comic-Con Masquerade.

Technically, the Masquerade is also a panel, but it's an event all to itself. It's the cosplay contest at Comic-Con, and this year is its 40th anniversary. The event takes over Hall 20, the second largest room in the convention center and seats 4,000 people. But it's also simulcast to two other large conference rooms and to the Sails Pavilion, a large open area on the upper floor which was also catered with free food. That brings the size of the live audience to over 6000! The Masquerade is a major celebration at Comic-Con and as I understand it (I've never been directly involved with the competition) competitors pretty much have to plan on spending the day getting applications, dealing with judging, and whatever pre-show engineering and production needs to happen (and of course, all the associated Line-Cons). It's hosted by Kaja and Phil Foglio, the geniuses behind the Girl Genius franchise. And they are delightful at MC duties. The top competitors are more than static presenters since full skits almost seem to be required nowadays. My personal favorites were the pieces that addressed the multiplicity of fan universes. One performer went through a series of fandom costumes (Star Wars, Harry Potter, Firefly, etc), tearing away one costume to reveal another underneath. Wonderful! The other was a group piece that introduced one skeptic to all the different fandoms (by song!), dressing him in one iconic article of clothing after another until he ended up with a conglomeration of pieces that was chaotic, yet recognizable. Brilliant! However, the winning piece was a group of women who had costumes that were inspired by various Kaiju, and they catwalked across a stage that was made up of faux skyscraper silouettes. They could kick them over in a stylized rampage through the city. It was sort of a fashion show/monster movie mashup. A reasonable (although to my mind, uninspired) winner.

The Saber Guild's show during the Masquerade's judging break.

Between the contestant presentations and the awards ceremony, while the judges are making their decisions, the Saber Guild presents a light saber combat show. I've seen several of their presentations, and this was the best so far. And, because so much of the crowd leaves after the contestants have finished, I was able to move up very close to the stage.

I love these guys and would dearly love to join this kind of performing troupe. It was the motivation for me to learn some theatrical fencing. Unfortunately, they're in Anaheim and that's just too far for me to join their practice sessions.


Of all the pictures I took at the panels, this one from the Best & Worst Manga 2014 is the best

As I mentioned before, I was really happy with the panels I saw and regret not taking the time to see more (minor regret, I don't really know what I'd cut out to make more time). Also, almost all of the pictures I took at the panels were terrible, so rather than subject you to all of those, I'll put up the only one I like and just resort to a brief description of the panels.

I saw two psychology themed panels: the Psychology of Cult TV Shows and the Psychology of Star Trek vs. Star Wars. Both were amazing, and there's definitely a new geek trend (genre, clique, topic, hobby?) around psychological analysis of our geeky loves. I'll be talking about this in another post.

Part of seeing those panels was getting a chance to meet my two favorite geek psychologists, Dr. Ali Matu and Dr. Andrea Letamendi. They both have podcasts that I listen to: Dr. Matu's Super Fantastic Nerd Hour and Dr. Letamendi's The Arkham Sessions. And that's what I mean, it's some sort of trend when I can have "favorite geek psychologists". I''l be talking a bit more about this later in this post.

I attended two panels about women characters. The first was called The Most Dangerous Women at Comic-Con, and the second was called Wonder Women of the 21st Century. Both were terrific panels, but I have now become a big fan of Adrianne Curry who was on both panels. She's a model and reality TV personality, and has an amazing perspective on the industry and women and characters in addition to being a big ol' geek.

I also attended a panel about the new Thunderbirds reboot happening. Weta (the studio doing all the special effects in the Hobbit & Lord of the Rings movies) is producing for ITC a remake of the old Thunderbirds show. I loved that show as a kid and saw it when it first came to the US. Seeing what they are doing with miniature models and some of their test video has rekindled that same excitement I felt when I saw trailers for the J.J. Abrams Star Trek remake. I can't wait!

David Peterson is the artist/writer behind the Mouse Guard franchise. It's really a beautiful series, and it's become popular enough to support a panel where he and his publisher discuss all the collectibles, games, and story lines coming up. The panel also included dramatic readings of three stories from a anthology of collected works by other creators in the Mouse Guard universe. It was very fun!

My manga expertise is almost non-existent, so I decided to attend the Best & Worst Manga of 2014 panel to begin edumacating myself. Four writers who review manga each discussed their top choice in a variety of categories. Here's a link to their choices. It provided me with a pretty nice reading list. I also got a chance to meet the reviewers so I can pick out who to following in the future (I haven't decided yet - still reviewing their on-line stuff). 

Okay, I had to include one other photo from a session, and that's this shot from the Klingon Lifestyles event. I mean, how could I not include a picture from a Klingon play?

My favorite session by far is the Klingon Lifestyles event. This panel has been put on at Comic-Con for 21 years now, and in many ways it expresses the pure geeky fan loyalty that Comic-Con represents. A group of very amateur performers in full costume and makeup (although some of the prosthetics are almost intentionally applied poorly) regale the audience with a play that follows the antics of the IKV Stranglehold, a warship of the Klingon Empire. The piece is filled with puns, inside jokes, and asides to the audience. It is unadulterated fun, and the audience loves it. Shouts of Qapla' ring out to greet the players, and I think everyone leaves with a smile on their face.

Some of the panels I discussed in other section : the cosplay special effects panel, the Masquerade, and the Eisner Awards.

Toys, Collectibles, and Stuff

This is just a representative sample of the stuff I brought back. Statues, plushies, models, key chains, reproductions, lightsaber, cards, games, and yup, that's a water bottle.

Yeah, this is when I realize I have some sort of problem. I came back with way too many toys and things. Action figures, statues, keychains (I don't use keychains), shirts, car floor mats (that's new!), reproductions (a phaser, starfleet academy ring, and gold coins from Smaug's hoard!), knitting kits (okay, those are gifts), a steampunk light saber, and on and on. There's less stuff than last year, but I don't even include the comics & artwork when I talk about this category.

Still, this is one of the amazing things that Comic-Con provides. Unique items that celebrate the characters, stories, worlds, and genres that we love as geeks. I don't really regret any of it.

Misc. Events

I attended my first Nerd HQ event and I really enjoyed what that crew has put together. I attended a Conversation for a Cause with Nathan Fillion, and the venue was very well organized, the theater was very intimate with the speaker, and the staff and volunteers were delightful. There's a lot more available in the main hall for the casual visitor, so I'm definitely spending more time here next year.

Nathan Fillion and Alan Tudyk at Nerd HQ's Conversation for a Cause.

Nathan Fillion is as delightful as I've always heard. He's personable, funny, very engaging with his fans, and seems well liked by his co-workers. For his talk, he brought Alan Tudyk on stage with him, and the two have a remarkable chemistry.  This was one of my highlights.

Another highlight was spending some time chatting with Dr. Ali Matu. As I mentioned in the panels section, I fist saw him at a Psychology of Star Trek vs. Star Wars panel at WonderCon, and then subscribed to his podcast Super Fantastic Nerd Hour. Before one of his panels at Comic-Con, I saw him waiting and walked up to tell him how much I enjoyed the show. We ended chatting about several things, and geeking out together on a couple of topics. The whole interaction was delightful and stands out as one of my best moments at Comic-Con.

Finally, my trip to San Diego every year is typically a very solo event. I rarely see friends there, and Harriet has no interest in attending the event (she's supportive, but not self-sacrificing). This year, however, I saw my niece who recently got married and moved to the area, and I reconnected with an old high school  friend I hadn't seen in 35 years. Although not part of the geek mecca, they were highlights of my trip.